1958 Rookie Cards

9 rookie cards across Football, Baseball, Hockey. Sorted by estimated gem mint value.

🏈 Football (3)⚾ Baseball (3)🏒 Hockey (3)
🏈 FootballRC

1958 Topps Jim Brown #62 RC

The greatest running back ever. Brown retired at peak, age 29, league MVP. No one has matched his dominance.

Raw
$3,000–$15,000 (PSA 5)
Gem Mint
$400,000+ (PSA 9)
🏈 FootballRC

1958 Topps Jim Brown #62

The RC of the greatest running back in NFL history. Brown retired at his peak having never been stopped by age or injury, and his vintage cards command serious collector premiums.

Raw
$1,500–$6,000 (PSA 7)
Gem Mint
$30,000+ (PSA 9)
⚾ BaseballRC

1958 Topps Roger Maris #47

The home run record holder's rookie card. Maris broke Ruth's single-season record with 61 homers in 1961, setting off one of the most controversial seasons in baseball history.

Raw
$200–$1,200 (PSA 7)
Gem Mint
$20,000+ (PSA 9)
🏒 HockeyRC

1958-59 Topps Bobby Hull #66

The Golden Jet had the hardest shot in hockey and was the first player to score more than 50 goals. A crossover star of the 1960s.

Raw
$200–$1,000 (PSA 5)
Gem Mint
$20,000+ (PSA 9)
⚾ BaseballRC

1958 Topps Brooks Robinson #307 RC

The Human Vacuum Cleaner's Topps RC. Robinson is considered the greatest defensive third baseman ever — 16 consecutive Gold Gloves and the 1970 World Series MVP performance that is still replayed today.

Raw
$100-$600 (PSA 5)
Gem Mint
$15,000+ (PSA 8)
⚾ BaseballRC

1958 Topps Orlando Cepeda RC #343

The rookie card of the Baby Bull, the powerful first baseman from Puerto Rico who burst onto the scene with the San Francisco Giants. Cepeda was a unanimous National League Rookie of the Year in 1958, hitting .312 with 25 home runs and establishing himself as one of the most dangerous hitters in the game.

Raw
$100–$500 (PSA 4)
Gem Mint
$10,000+ (PSA 8)
🏈 FootballRC

1958 Topps Tommy McDonald RC #127

Tommy McDonald famously played without a facemask throughout his career. His 1958 Topps rookie card is a key Philadelphia Eagles vintage issue from the 1960 NFL Championship team.

Raw
$20–$80
Gem Mint
$800–$2,500
🏒 HockeyRC

1958-59 Topps Johnny Bucyk RC #40

Johnny "Chief" Bucyk played 1,436 NHL games in the Bruins top line alongside Phil Esposito and Ken Hodge. His 1958-59 Topps rookie card is a key Bruins vintage collectible.

Raw
$20–$80
Gem Mint
$800–$2,500
🏒 HockeyRC

1958-59 Topps Norm Ullman RC #58

Norm Ullman scored 490 career goals and was one of the most consistent scorers in NHL history. His 1958-59 Topps rookie card is a key vintage hockey issue.

Raw
$15–$60
Gem Mint
$500–$1,500