Trade Evaluator
Is this trade fair? Add cards to both sides, toggle between raw and graded values, and see who's getting the better deal.
Side A — You're Giving
$0Add cards to this side of the trade
Side B — You're Getting
$0Add cards to this side of the trade
How to Use the Trade Evaluator
Add Cards to Side A
Search for cards you're giving in the trade. Toggle between raw and graded values.
Add Cards to Side B
Search for cards you're receiving. Build up both sides of the trade.
See the Verdict
We compare total estimated values and tell you who's getting the better deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you determine card values for trades?
We use estimated market values based on recent eBay sold listings and market data. Raw values represent ungraded card prices, while graded values represent gem mint (PSA 10 / BGS 9.5) prices. Always verify with actual recent sales before finalizing any trade.
What makes a fair trade?
A fair trade is one where both sides are within 10% of each other in total market value. But value isn't everything — consider which cards better fit your collection goals, which have more upside potential, and which are harder to find. A "losing" trade on paper can be a win if you're getting a card you've been chasing.
Should I always trade for equal value?
Not necessarily. Trade for what you want to own. If you're getting your personal grail card, paying a small premium is worth it. If you're trading away a card you don't care about, getting 80% of its value in a card you love is a win. Value is one input, not the only input.
How do I trade cards safely?
For in-person trades, meet at a card shop or public place. For online trades, use a trusted middleman service or trade on platforms with buyer protection (eBay, COMC, Sportlots). Never ship first to an unverified trader. Document everything with photos before and after.